Anyway on a different note can @yudilevi or anyone explain

Question

Bancor Protocol

Sai

Anyway on a different note can @yudilevi or anyone explain

what's keeps us from using the surplus in v2.1? Is it because if we bring the surplus that will simply help lps leave?

#bancor #blockchain #cryptocurrency #english

0

12.08.2022

16 ответов

26 просмотров

Sai Автор вопроса

Yudi Levi | Bancor
No, it’s just very subjective who this surplus bel...

What do you mean who? Everything is socialized now. I'm sure v,2.1 lps will be happy with 0 deficit. They are not going to come asking for their share id surplus in such a situation. So why can't the surplus be used by protocol

0

12.08.2022

Yudi Levi | Bancor

Sai
What do you mean who? Everything is socialized now...

Imagine the surplus is migrated and the rate changes in the pools create a deficit in them

0

12.08.2022

Alex Alex

I spent 1.5 years in v2.1 and migrated to v3 in june,so yeah,it’s subjective

0

12.08.2022

infoparity

Sai
What do you mean who? Everything is socialized now...

I don't think 2.1 LPs in surplus pools should be made 100% whole. I think their deficit specific positions should be honored for direct withdrawal from v2.1. The surplus is up for debate given the situation. Technically it is LP generated but based on the smart contract protocol design the surplus is owned by the protocol. It's how it could even create the opportunity to pay ILP. I'd lean that it is pool specific and shouldn't be shared across the holistic v3 personally. May be best to just create a claim on the surplus from the historical 2.1 LPs who stayed in up until 6/19 in proportion to their weight in the pool.

0

13.08.2022

Andrew

infoparity
I don't think 2.1 LPs in surplus pools should be m...

Am in v3 now but I was in v2.1 I'm not asking for interest I'm just asking for my original deposit

0

13.08.2022

infoparity

Andrew
Am in v3 now but I was in v2.1 I'm not asking for ...

I think the surplus should be distributed based on the weight of your 2.1 position prior to the 6/19 shutoff for anyone who was in 2.1 or 3 at the that 6/19 date personally

0

13.08.2022

Timbuktu

Alex Alex
I spent 1.5 years in v2.1 and migrated to v3 in ju...

EXACTLY this. Most of my time spent is in v2.1, well over a year. And I moved to v3 only a few months ago. Subjectively, the surplus belongs to anyone who migrated from v2.1 to v3 and who is currently in v2.1

0

16.08.2022

Terry

Timbuktu
EXACTLY this. Most of my time spent is in v2.1, we...

It’s not about how long you spent in the pool though

0

16.08.2022

Timbuktu

Terry
It’s not about how long you spent in the pool thou...

Go on

0

16.08.2022

Terry

Timbuktu
Go on

Depends on when you deposited

0

16.08.2022

Timbuktu

Terry
Depends on when you deposited

Sorry if that wasn't clear. Yes, when you deposited into v2.1

0

16.08.2022

Terry

Timbuktu
Sorry if that wasn't clear. Yes, when you deposite...

Look buddy, I lost money too so don’t get mad

0

16.08.2022

Timbuktu

What isn't clear? The v2.1 applies to folks who were lpers in v2.1, whether they are still in v 2.1 or migrated. Not soley for the folks who didn't migrate

0

16.08.2022

Gilly

Timbuktu
What isn't clear? The v2.1 applies to folks who we...

This

0

16.08.2022

Terry

Gilly
This

Not really though

0

16.08.2022