Im guessing you are connected via vpn but github actions

I'm not familiar with how the registry (and s3) works under the hood, but it seems strange to me that a direct connection is established between the client and MinIO since I push to the registry. It would be like saying that in a SPA (Single Page Application), the user writes directly to the database 🤯

0

27 дней назад

Sharuzzaman Ahmat Raslan

ƒabio
I'm not familiar with how the registry (and s3) wo...

Github Action is not a Single Page Application. It has a backend system. When you build the image and need to push to the registry, the same process will happen with Github Action. And the registry need a storage which is your MinIO

0

27 дней назад

ƒabio

Sharuzzaman Ahmat Raslan
Github Action is not a Single Page Application. It...

Yes, of course, but the point is: why does the client (GitHub action) have to connect directly to MinIO when it pushes to the registry? Isn’t it enough that the registry is reachable? It should be the registry that handles uploading to MinIO, not the client

0

27 дней назад

Raptor Blue Bear

ƒabio
Yes, of course, but the point is: why does the cli...

Because it's a privately hosted registry that Github action does not have access to

0

27 дней назад

ƒabio

Raptor Blue Bear
Because it's a privately hosted registry that Gith...

No, the registry is publicly accessible. Only MinIO is private

0

27 дней назад

Sharuzzaman Ahmat Raslan

ƒabio
Yes, of course, but the point is: why does the cli...

How do you verify Github Action is accessing your MinIO directly?

0

27 дней назад

ƒabio

Sharuzzaman Ahmat Raslan
How do you verify Github Action is accessing your ...

If I use the registry with filesystem storage, it works perfectly. Even if I establish a VPN between the client and MinIO, everything works. Moreover, the GitHub timeout indicates MinIO's private IP

0

27 дней назад

Sharuzzaman Ahmat Raslan

ƒabio
If I use the registry with filesystem storage, it ...

What is "client" here?

0

27 дней назад

ƒabio

Sharuzzaman Ahmat Raslan
What is "client" here?

Me, I tried a docker push from my PC: - If I am connected to the VPN, the push works (and i see it in minio bucket) - If I am not connected to the VPN, the push does not work. The VPN allows me to reach MinIO. The registry is always accessible from the internet domain. - Github works if registry uses filestorage instead of s3

0

27 дней назад

Sharuzzaman Ahmat Raslan

ƒabio
Me, I tried a docker push from my PC: - If I am c...

Where is the registry located? How do you connect to registry? Using IP address?

0

27 дней назад

ƒabio

Sharuzzaman Ahmat Raslan
Where is the registry located? How do you connect ...

I access the registry via 'registry.example.com' which is located on Server A. The MinIO container is on Server B. Servers A and B are connected through the Tailscale VPN

0

27 дней назад

Sharuzzaman Ahmat Raslan

ƒabio
I access the registry via 'registry.example.com' w...

In registry, how does it know how to contact MinIO? You put MinIO IP address in registry configuration?

0

27 дней назад

ƒabio

Sharuzzaman Ahmat Raslan
In registry, how does it know how to contact MinIO...

Yes ofc

0

27 дней назад